The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
This study investigated the healthcare provider’s knowledge and attitudes towards induced abortion in Rwanda. A total of 152 healthcare providers from six public hospitals in Kigali city participated in this study. Questionnaires were used to record data on demographics, level of knowledge and attitudes towards abortion law then be cleaned, coded and entered into Excel sheet. Then all data were exported into SPSS version 22 for final cleaning and analysis. The study findings revealed that 54.6% were female, 56.0% were single, and 73% participants said that they attended formal training on abortion care. The study findings revealed that 23.70% healthcare providers had poor knowledge towards legal abortion law, and 57.20% had positive attitude with regards to induced abortion law. The findings revealed that religion and formal training on abortion care were among the factors which were strongly influencing attitudes of health care providers towards induced abortion where protestants were unlikely to have positive attitude with regards to induced abortion (AOR=0.277; 95% CI=0.027-0.377; P=<0.001) compared to participants belonged to catholic religion and participants who were not trained were unlikely to have positive attitude with regards to induced abortion (AOR=0.696; 95% CI=0.056-0.721; P=0.048) compared to trained respondents. It concludes that marital status, category of caregiver, religion, formal training on abortion and level of knowledge were the main risk factors of level of attitude towards induced abortion. More training about induced abortion are highly needed among health care providers to increase related knowledge as well as to eliminate negative attitude towards induced abortion.
In 2017, the WHO reported that clandestine abortions keep being meaningful cause of maternal mortality and morbidity globally. It was counted that; worldwide over 56 million induced abortions occurred within a period of 2010–2014. In developed countries, reports highlighted a significant decline in abortions between 1994 and 2014. In fact, all causes abortions represented 39% and 27% of all pregnancies, respectively. However, developing countries still struggled with increasing abortion rates in the same period. Abortion rates increased from about 21% to 24% between 1994 and 2014
In least developed nations with more prohibitive abortion laws, safe and medical induced abortion is not always accessible to women and girls having even sometimes-legal authorization. Despite the utmost important place of health care professionals in providing legalized abortion care services, their shortfall and lack of willingness to do so constitute the main challenges for abortion services
According to the WHO 2016 report, of about 4.2 million women who underwent clandestine abortion in Africa and each year, nearly 1% lost their lives due to abortion-related complications. For example, Kenya has registered an estimated 464,000 induced abortions for only 2012 with almost a ratio of 30 abortions over 100 live births
In Brazil, there are already ample knowledge on induced abortion and medical professionals, whereby a study done on 572 obstetrician-gynecologists only 48% reported accurate knowledge on abortion law
In Ghana, where also abortion is allowed under certain circumstances, a study revealed that, most of midwives were not able to show a good understanding of abortion law and some had a wrong interpretation of the nature of abortion law
However, seen in some cases that health care professionals are conversant with legal abortion laws in their countries some are left behind. This can be seen in a study conducted in Argentina where the health care providers had not gotten sufficient knowledge on legal abortion policies within the country
A study conducted among 405 mid-level healthcare providers 71.9% knew the contextualized definition of legal abortion in Ethiopia, 81.5% of them were conversant with the revised abortion law and only 53.1% of them had good knowledge on medical abortion care and only 54.1% of them had positive attitude towards safe abortion. Another study done in Ethiopia revealed that almost 54.1% mid-level HCPs had positive attitude towards medical abortion, and furthermore, HCPs with sufficient knowledge on medical abortion and male providers were more likely to show positive attitude with regards to medical abortion
In the USA, a study was done on 278 physicians working in SHR services. Almost all strongly agreed that abortion can be provided in cases of pregnancy resulted from rape (89.6%), incest (89.2%), health risk (91.0%), and fetal abnormality (85.9%)
In Ethiopia, it has been seen that healthcare providers have a more favorable views and attitude towards the providing safe abortion services, which is partially promoted due to an enabling environment. The result is that the majority of HCPs had a positive attitude towards medical abortion services
Furthermore a greater number of health care providers (67.3%) had unfavorable attitudes towards induced abortion in Pakistan
In Mexico about (71.1%) of healthcare providers supported abortion under certain circumstances and specifically, the majority (88.8%) support induced abortion for grounds where the pregnancy place at risk the life of the mother, when pregnancy results from rape (83.5%), and in case of fetal anomalies (83.5%)
On the other hand in Zimbabwe, most healthcare providers were in support of liberalizing abortion law specifically to grounds when the pregnancy place risk of mother’s life (65%) and in cases when a mother is mentally handicapped (66%)
The 1977 Rwanda abortion legislation restricted abortion; this was allowed only while preserving the health of a woman. In fact, abortion was illegal. Back in 2012, Rwanda approved abortion legislation and abortion was permissible in following cases of incest, rape, forced marriage and when there is a health-related problem either for pregnant woman or the fetus.
Since 2012 till later 2018, to obtain a legal abortion; a woman or girls looking for abortion was supposed to bring a certification from a “competent Court” explaining that the pregnant was resulted from incest, rape, or in forced marriage. To obtain a legal abortion because women/girls health related issue, one must get permission from two doctors with a written report in three copies
Despite restrictive abortion legislation in Rwanda, nearly 60,000 induced abortions were registered from 2009 to 2012, with a rate of 25 abortions per 1,000 women and girls aged between 15 to 44 years over one year
Recently in 2019, a ministerial order was released in the official Gazette no.14 of 08/04/2019 removing those pre-conditions of obtaining a court order and two doctors’ approval in order to access a safe abortion. Now, one doctor can perform abortion without requiring court order only in following cases: when the pregnant person is a child; in case of rape; in case pregnant woman was subjected to a forced marriage, in case of pregnancy resulted from incest pledged with a man to the second degree of kinship, and lastly when the pregnancy present a risk to the health of the mother or to the foetus.
Kigali, the nation’s capital, registers a disproportionate figures of abortions relative to its total population; almost one-third of country’s abortions cases occur in Kigali city, although its host only one-tenth of the Rwanda’s women and girls of reproductive age
The present study investigated health care providers’ knowledge and views that shape the provision of abortion services. The results from this study enabled the country understand provider opinions on abortion and their implications policy implementation.
The study used cross-sectional and quantitative approaches with the aim to investigate healthcare providers’ level of knowledge on current abortion law. Here, the goal was to found out beliefs of individuals on the nature of a particular phenomenon
The study was conducted in Kigali City within 6 public hospitals of Kigali city: Kigali University Teaching Hospital, Muhima District Hospital, Kacyiru District Hospital, Kibagabaga District Hospital, Masaka district hospital and Rwanda Military Hospital. The Kigali city has women fertility rate of 3.6%, which is the least compared to other provinces of Rwanda (RDHS 2014/15).
The city has higher rates of unplanned pregnancies resulting to clandestine abortion and consequently 18 cases per 1,000 women who had abortion being treated for complications
The research included medical providers working in maternity units from the 6 public hospitals of Kigali city which includes: Kigali University Teaching Hospital, Muhima District Hospital, Kacyiru District Hospital, Kibagabaga District Hospital, Masaka district hospital and Rwanda Military Hospital. Study participants were nurses, doctors, and midwives of all age group, educational qualification, and gender. The diversity of this group allowed the researcher to adequately exploring the knowledge and attitudes of those providers on the abortion for health purposes. Approximately 300 healthcare providers (nurses, doctors, and midwives) work in the targeted hospitals.
At the beginning, a random sampling was used to select study participants out of the population size. The sample size was stratified and we used 2 subgroups such as medical doctors and nurses/midwives. The total population is made of 100 medical doctors and 200 nurses/midwives making approximately 33.3% and 66.7% proportions respectively. Therefore, those proportions were applied to our sample population and there were 50 medical doctors and 102 nurses/midwives study participants. Further stratification was done according to the health facilities included (6 hospitals) and according to the total of 300 healthcare providers included (60 health care providers from Kigali University Teaching Hospital, 50 healthcare providers from Muhima District Hospital, 50 healthcare providers from Kacyiru District Hospital, 44 healthcare providers from Kibagabaga District Hospital, 40 healthcare providers from Masaka district hospital and 56 healthcare providers Rwanda Military Hospital). The proportions of total sample size were as follow; 31 health care providers from Kigali University Teaching Hospital, 25 healthcare providers from Muhima District Hospital, 25 healthcare providers from Kacyiru District Hospital, 22 healthcare providers from Kibagabaga District Hospital, 20 healthcare providers from Masaka district hospital and 29 healthcare providers Rwanda Military Hospital making a total of 152 participants.
Data were collected using structured questionnaire, which was conceptualized, based on research objectives to answers each of research questions. This research questionnaire contained the dependent variable and independent variables that enabled researcher to determine the level of knowledge and attitude of health care providers as well as to answer the last research question, which consists of factors influencing providers’ attitude towards induced abortion in Kigali city, Rwanda.
Data analysis was done using quantitative methods; questionnaires were cleaned, variables were coded and launched into Excel sheet. Categorical data on knowledge on abortion law among healthcare providers (Yes, No and I don't know) were classified as good knowledge (above the mean) or poor knowledge (less than the mean). On the other hand, categorical data on attitudes of healthcare providers towards induced abortion (Agree and Disagree) were classified as positive attitude (above the mean) and negative attitude (less than the mean).
All data was then exported to SPSS version 22 for final cleaning and analysis. A descriptive analysis of demographic information was performed to identify frequency distributions, proportions, and proportions of participants. The chi-square test was performed to determine the association between categorical variables (knowledge and attitude demographics). Finally, we used logistic regression to determine the association between the dependent and independent variables with 95% confidence intervals.
At the beginning of the study, the data collection authorization letter was given by Mount Kenya University. Prior to data collection, research respondents were communicated the nature and sensitivity of the research and further ethical clearances were obtained from Hospital ethics committees where existing. Anonymity and confidentiality maintained and respondents protected by not disclosing any information potentially linked to them. All participants were informed that they allowed quitting from the study anytime they are not confortable with it. Due to the sensitivity of the information that was provided by the health care providers, the researcher ensured study participants that the information is only used for research purposes only, and no personal information that was link to the respondents were disclosed.
As indicated in
The
|
|
|
---|---|---|
|
||
20-30 Years | 38 | 25 |
31-40 Years | 78 | 51.3 |
>40 years | 36 | 23.7 |
|
||
Male | 69 | 45.4 |
Female | 83 | 54.6 |
|
||
Married | 68 | 44 |
Single | 84 | 56 |
|
||
Catholic | 69 | 45.4 |
Protestant | 83 | 54.6 |
|
||
Yes | 111 | 73 |
No | 41 | 27 |
|
||
GP | 25 | 16.4 |
GO Specialist | 17 | 11.2 |
GO Resident | 9 | 5.9 |
Midwife | 62 | 40.8 |
Nurse | 39 | 25.7 |
|
||
1-10 Years | 100 | 65.8 |
11-20Years | 41 | 27 |
>20Years | 11 | 7.2 |
Source: Primary data
The objective one was to determine HCPs’ level of knowledge on Rwandan legal abortion law and was measured by score assessment of thirteen variables.
Among the participants, 148(97.4%) of them agreed that they knew that there is abortion legislation in Rwanda, 101(66.0%) participants said that all medical doctors are granted to provide abortion services and 136(89.9%) of them were agreed with the statement which was asking if abortion is allowed when a child aged less than 18 years. 130(85.5%) of respondents agreed with the statement which was asking whether abortion is allowed in case to pregnant person with forced marriage while 131(86.2%) of them were not agree with the statement which was asking if abortion is allowed in case of the person who requesting for it can’t afford a child. (
|
|
|
---|---|---|
|
||
No | 4 | 2.6 |
Yes | 148 | 97.4 |
|
||
Yes | 120 | 78.9 |
No | 22 | 14.5 |
I don't know | 10 | 6.6 |
|
||
Yes | 101 | 66.4 |
No | 35 | 23 |
I don't know | 16 | 10.5 |
|
||
Yes | 64 | 42.1 |
No | 76 | 50 |
I don't know | 12 | 7.9 |
|
||
Yes | 136 | 89.5 |
No | 13 | 8.6 |
I don't know | 3 | 2 |
|
||
Yes | 20 | 13.2 |
No | 129 | 84.9 |
I don't know | 3 | 2 |
|
||
Yes | 139 | 91.4 |
No | 8 | 5.3 |
I don't know | 5 | 3.3 |
|
||
Yes | 130 | 85.5 |
No | 15 | 9.9 |
I don't know | 7 | 4.6 |
|
||
Yes | 131 | 86.2 |
No | 12 | 7.9 |
I don't know | 9 | 5.9 |
|
||
Yes | 147 | 96.7 |
No | 5 | 3.3 |
|
||
Yes | 62 | 40.8 |
No | 66 | 43.4 |
I don't know | 24 | 15.8 |
|
||
Yes | 17 | 11.2 |
No | 131 | 86.2 |
I don't know | 4 | 2.6 |
|
||
Yes | 20 | 13.2 |
No | 126 | 82.9 |
I don't know | 6 | 3.9 |
The overall score is 13 and its mean is 9.60. The scores are 0 and 1 for No and Yes respectively and the results are presented in
The study findings revealed that the majority of health care providers in Kigali of 116(76.30%) had good knowledge towards Rwandan legal abortion law and few of respondents 36(23.70%) had poor knowledge towards Rwandan legal abortion law.
The objective two was to assess attitudes towards induced abortion law among HCPs and was also measured by score assessment of six variables.
For assessing an attitude of health care providers in Kigali, six statements have been used. Among the participants, 96(63.2%) of them agreed the statement that was asking whether they agree with any of the grounds under which abortion is allowed in Rwanda and 93(61.2%) supported the statement saying that the abortion done when the person who looking for it is aged under eighteen. For the statement that was asking whether abortion is allowed in case of the person who asking for abortion wasraped, 54(35.5%) of the respondents did agree that statement while 143(94.1%) of respondents agreed the statement asked whether the abortion should be done in case of thepregnancy place at risk the health of the mother. (
|
|
|
---|---|---|
I agree | 96 | 63.2 |
I disagree | 56 | 36.8 |
|
||
I agree | 93 | 61.2 |
I disagree | 59 | 38.8 |
|
||
I agree | 98 | 64.5 |
I disagree | 54 | 35.5 |
|
||
I agree | 89 | 58.6 |
I disagree | 63 | 41.4 |
|
||
I agree | 91 | 59.9 |
I disagree | 61 | 40.1 |
|
||
I agree | 143 | 94.1 |
I disagree | 9 | 5.9 |
The overall score is 6 and its mean is 4.01. The scores are 0 and 1 for I disagree and I agree respectively and the results are presented in
The study findings showed that over a half of HCPs 87(57.20%) had positive attitude towards induced abortion law and 65(42.80%) HCPs had negative attitude towards induced abortion law.
Objective three was to determine factors influencing attitudes of healthcare providers towards induced abortion in Kigali and was calculated by using the assessment of variables presented in
|
|
|
|
|
---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|||
|
||||
Married | Ref | |||
Single | 0.693 | 0.32 | 1.503 | 0.353 |
|
||||
GP | Ref | |||
GO Specialist | 1.991 | 0.575 | 6.897 | 0.277 |
Midwife | 1.314 | 0.334 | 5.175 | 0.696 |
Nurse | 0.863 | 0.346 | 2.152 | 0.752 |
|
||||
Catholic | Ref | |||
Protestant | 0.277 | 0.027 | 0.377 |
|
|
||||
No | 0.696 | 0.056 | 0.721 |
|
Yes | Ref | |||
|
||||
Poor knowledge | 0.752 | 0.752 | 0.752 | 0.11 |
Good knowledge | Ref |
Multivariate analysis was performed in this study to check how strong association was between variables.
Findings revealed that the religion was among the factors which was strongly influencing attitudes of HCPs towards induced abortion where protestants were unlikely to have positive attitude with regards to induced abortion (AOR=0.277; 95% CI=0.027-0.377; P=<0.001) compared to participants belonged to catholic religion. Formal training on abortion care, shown to be the factor influencing attitudes of HCPs towards induced abortion where participants who were not trained were unlikely to have positive attitude with regards to induced abortion (AOR=0.696; 95% CI=0.056-0.721; P=0.048) compared to trained respondents.
This study intended to investigate healthcare provider’s knowledge and attitudes towards induced abortion in public hospitals of Kigali city, Rwanda. The present study revealed that over a half of healthcare providers 76.3% had good knowledge and 57.20% had positive attitude towards induced abortion law.
Healthcare provider’s knowledge about abortion law in Rwanda is almost the same compared to that reported in a study conducted in Ethiopia where only 71.9% healthcare providers knew the definition of abortion, 53.1% of them had sufficient knowledge on medical abortion and about 81.5% of them were conversant with the country’s abortion law
On the other hand, healthcare provider’s knowledge about abortion law in Rwanda was higher compared to Brazilian medical professionals where only 48% medical professionals out of 572 obstetrician-gynecologists reported accurate knowledge on abortion law
The different in percentages of health care providers with good knowledge in Rwanda and the two countries; Zimbabwe and Brazil, maybe linked with the differences in terms of abortion legislations in these countries. Both Brazil and Zimbabwe have very restrictive abortion laws that only permit abortion in cases of rape, fetal abnormalities, or risk to life of the mother.
The present findings revealed that over a half of health care providers 57.20% had positive attitude towards induced abortion law and 42.80% health care providers had negative attitude towards induced abortion law. The level of attitude was assessed by asking the questions related to an induced abortion law in Rwanda, where the respondents would answer the questions by supporting or not supporting each of the grounds under which abortion is allowed in Rwanda.
These findings were in the line with other three studies done in Ethiopia, India and Mexico where by almost 54.1% mid-level healthcare providers in Ethiopia had positive attitude towards safe abortion
On the other hand, the majority of health care providers in Pakistan (67.3%) had unfavorable attitudes towards induced abortion
The most factors influencing healthcare providers’ attitudes towards induced abortion in Kigali generally are; marital status, category of caregiver, religion, formal training on abortion and level of knowledge. For the factors which influencing the attitude towards induced abortion, specifically religion and formal related training showed to be the factors with strong association with healthcare providers’ attitude towards induced abortion in Kigali.
The present study was in the same line with the study conducted from South Africa, which concluded that, both training on medical abortion and certification of midwives were identified as factors influencing positive attitude towards induced abortion and this led to a critical step during providing of quality medical abortion services. The same applied on the religion as one of the factor influencing attitude among health care providers, this study found out that religious, moral beliefs and fears contributed much in taking decision of being involved in an induced abortion
Religion was also one of the key factors influencing healthcare providers’ attitude towards abortion care in Ethiopia
The study’s aim was to investigate healthcare provider’s knowledge and attitudes towards induced abortion in public hospitals of Kigali city, Rwanda.
The finding of this study revealed that that the majority of health care providers in Kigali had good knowledge towards Rwandan legal abortion law and lower percentage of respondents had poor knowledge towards Rwandan legal abortion law. Although, this study revealed marital status, category of caregiver, religion, formal training on abortion and level of knowledge were the main risk factors of level of attitude towards induced abortion.
The result can’t be generalized for whole country in consideration of the study design, sample size and the characteristics of study population (health care providers) in urban area that can differ from those characteristics in rural. Further studies including qualitative methods related to abortion law in Rwanda in Kigali and even countrywide is recommended as we are still having a high number of clandestine abortions.